Comparison
Only Natural Pet Alternatives: Best Brands & Retailers
Table of Contents
- Why Pet Owners Switch From Only Natural Pet
- Best Natural Dog Food Brands as Alternatives
- What to Look for in Natural Pet Food
- Best Online Pet Supply Stores for Convenient Delivery
- How to Switch Pet Food Brands Safely
- Pricing and Value Comparison
- Frequently Asked Questions
Last Updated: September 28, 2026
Why Pet Owners Switch From Only Natural Pet
Many pet owners who initially chose Only Natural Pet eventually explore an Only Natural Pet alternative for specific reasons. Some discover that their dog's digestive system responds better to different protein sources or ingredient profiles. Others find that ingredient transparency and sourcing practices matter more than they initially expected. Cost considerations also play a role, premium natural formulas can strain household budgets when feeding multiple pets or larger breeds.
The shift toward alternatives reflects a broader trend in pet nutrition. Owners increasingly want to match their dog's individual needs rather than settle for a one-size-fits-all approach. This guide from Best Online Pets Supply explores natural dog food brands as an Only Natural Pet alternative available today, helping you find the right fit for your pet's health, budget, and lifestyle.
Best Natural Dog Food Brands as Alternatives
Finding the right natural dog food brand requires understanding what sets each option apart. The alternatives below represent different approaches to holistic nutrition, ingredient quality, and price points.

Nulo: High-Protein, Probiotic-Enriched Nutrition
Nulo focuses on high-meat, low-carb formulas designed to support metabolic health and digestive wellness. The brand includes GanedenBC30 probiotics in its recipes. This approach appeals to owners seeking premium nutrition without corn, wheat, soy, or artificial preservatives.
Nulo's recipes emphasize high-quality protein sources and minimal carbohydrates. The brand formulates options for different life stages and activity levels, making it suitable for puppies, active dogs, and senior pets.
The main consideration with Nulo is the price point. Premium formulations cost more than standard kibble, though Best Online Pets Supply's free shipping on orders over $99 helps offset that cost. For owners prioritizing metabolic health and digestive support, the investment often feels justified.
NutriSource: Quality at a Reasonable Price
NutriSource represents a middle ground between budget-friendly and premium brands. The family-owned company uses its proprietary Good 4 Life system, which combines probiotics, omega fatty acids, and antioxidants. This makes NutriSource appealing to budget-conscious owners who don't want to compromise on quality.
The brand offers extensive variety across life stages, breed sizes, and dietary needs. Recipes feature high-quality proteins like chicken, lamb, and salmon.
Availability can be limited in some big-box retail stores, but ordering through Best Online Pets Supply ensures consistent access. The combination of quality ingredients, digestive support, and reasonable pricing makes NutriSource a practical alternative for most households.
American Natural Premium: Small-Batch Transparency
American Natural Premium distinguishes itself through small-batch production and ingredient transparency. Many formulations use human-grade ingredients, appealing to owners who want to know exactly what their dog is eating.
The focus on small-batch quality control means less variation between batches and greater attention to ingredient sourcing.
The trade-off is less brand recognition compared to major national retailers. However, the transparent sourcing and digestibility benefits appeal to owners willing to research their choices. American Natural Premium represents a thoughtful alternative for those prioritizing ingredient quality and digestive health.
PawCo: Plant-Based Alternative for Allergies
PawCo specializes in nutritionally complete vegan dog food formulated for dogs with meat-based protein allergies. The recipes use high-protein, low-fat plant-based ingredients. This makes PawCo unique among natural alternatives for dogs with specific protein sensitivities.
The brand appeals to environmentally conscious owners seeking sustainable, plant-based options. For dogs with documented meat allergies, PawCo offers a hypoallergenic approach that traditional natural brands cannot match.
PawCo works best for specific use cases, primarily dogs with meat allergies or owners prioritizing environmental sustainability. It's not designed for owners seeking raw or meat-based diets. Understanding your dog's actual dietary needs determines whether PawCo is the right fit.
What to Look for in Natural Pet Food
Choosing a natural dog food brand requires evaluating several key factors beyond marketing claims. However, the most critical decision point for most pet owners is identifying whether a formula matches their dog's specific sensitivities or allergies, an area where generic guidance falls short.
Ingredient Transparency and Sourcing matter most as a foundation. You should easily identify the primary protein sources and understand what each ingredient contributes to your dog's nutrition. Brands that clearly list sourcing practices, manufacturing methods, and batch testing build stronger trust.
Protein Source Identification for Allergy Management is where most pet owners need concrete guidance. Dogs with chicken sensitivities require formulas using alternative proteins like beef, lamb, duck, venison, or fish. However, many brands use chicken by-products or chicken meal in unexpected places (broths, supplements, or vitamin premixes).
Grain and Carbohydrate Profiles directly affect dogs with grain sensitivities. Grain-free doesn't automatically mean low-carb, many grain-free formulas substitute peas, potatoes, or tapioca starch, which can trigger sensitivities in sensitive dogs.
Digestibility and Nutrient Bioavailability affect how well your dog absorbs nutrition.
Life Stage and Health-Specific Formulations ensure appropriate nutrition at each phase. Puppies need higher calcium and phosphorus ratios for bone development (Checking your browser).
AAFCO Certification and Feeding Trials provide baseline assurance.
Best Online Pet Supply Stores for Convenient Delivery
Online shopping for natural pet food eliminates the burden of carrying heavy bags and ensures consistent access to your chosen brand. Best Online Pets Supply specializes in delivering high-quality natural dog food brands with free shipping on orders over $99, making it convenient to maintain your pet's nutrition without extra trips.
How to Switch Pet Food Brands Safely
Transitioning to a new natural dog food requires a structured protocol that accounts for your individual dog's digestive sensitivity. The standard 7-10 day transition works for most dogs, but sensitive or older dogs often need extended protocols and closer monitoring.
Standard Transition Protocol (7-10 Days)
- Days 1-2: Mix 25% new food with 75% old food
- Days 3-4: Mix 50% new food with 50% old food
- Days 5-6: Mix 75% new food with 25% old food
- Days 7+: Transition to 100% new food
Extended Transition for Sensitive Dogs (14-21 Days)
- Days 1-3: Mix 10% new food with 90% old food
- Days 4-6: Mix 25% new food with 75% old food
- Days 7-9: Mix 50% new food with 50% old food
- Days 10-12: Mix 75% new food with 25% old food
- Days 13+: Transition to 100% new food
Monitoring During Transition
Keep a detailed food journal tracking these metrics daily:
- Stool consistency: Note whether stools are firm, soft, or loose. Slight softening is normal; persistent diarrhea signals you need to slow the transition further.
- Appetite and energy: A dog eating less or showing reduced energy may indicate the new food isn't palatable or is causing mild digestive stress.
- Vomiting or regurgitation: Any vomiting during transition means reverting to the previous ratio for 2-3 additional days before advancing.
- Coat and skin changes:
- Gas and bloating: Excessive gas during transition is common.
When to Slow Down or Seek Veterinary Guidance
- Loose stools lasting more than 1-2 days
- Vomiting or retching
- Loss of appetite (eating less than 75% of normal portions)
- Excessive gas or visible abdominal discomfort
- Lethargy or unusual behavior
Special Considerations for Prescription or Therapeutic Diets
Pricing and Value Comparison
| Brand | Price Range | Best For | Key Feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nulo | Premium | Active dogs, metabolic health | High-protein, probiotic formula |
| NutriSource | Mid-range | Budget-conscious owners | Good value with digestive support |
| American Natural Premium | Premium | Sensitive digestion | Small-batch, high digestibility |
| PawCo | Premium | Meat allergies | Plant-based, sustainable |
Natural dog food pricing depends on ingredient quality, sourcing practices, and manufacturing methods. Premium brands with transparent sourcing and specialized formulations cost more than conventional kibble, but many owners find the health benefits justify the investment.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best alternatives to Only Natural Pet for holistic food?
Top natural pet food alternatives include Nulo for high-protein formulas with probiotics, NutriSource for quality at accessible prices, American Natural Premium for ingredient transparency, and PawCo for plant-based options. Each brand emphasizes holistic nutrition through different approaches: Nulo focuses on metabolic health, NutriSource uses their proprietary Good 4 Life gut health system, American Natural Premium prioritizes digestibility, and PawCo offers sustainable plant-based formulas. The best choice depends on your pet's specific health needs, dietary restrictions, and your priorities around cost and sourcing.
How do I choose a healthy pet food brand that's right for my dog?
Look for brands that list specific meat proteins as primary ingredients, avoid artificial preservatives and fillers, and provide clear nutritional profiles. Check for ingredient transparency, AAFCO certification, and whether the brand addresses your dog's specific needs (grain-free, hypoallergenic, joint support, or digestive health). Consult your veterinarian about your dog's individual requirements, especially if she has a sensitive stomach or known allergies.
Are there more affordable natural pet food options that don't sacrifice quality?
Yes. NutriSource offers high-quality natural ingredients at a more accessible price point than premium boutique brands, making it a strong budget-conscious choice without compromising on nutritional standards. American Natural Premium also provides excellent quality-to-value ratios with small-batch production. When comparing alternatives to Only Natural Pet, consider the cost-per-serving rather than just the bag price, as higher nutrient density means smaller portions may be needed. Online retailers offering free shipping on qualifying orders can also reduce your overall expenses.
What's the safest way to transition my pet to a new food brand?
Transition gradually over 7-10 days by mixing increasing amounts of the new food with the old food. Start with 25% new food and 75% old food for the first few days, then gradually increase the new food ratio every 2-3 days until you reach 100% new food. This slow transition helps prevent digestive upset. Monitor your pet for any signs of stomach sensitivity during the transition, and if issues occur, slow the process further.
Finding the right natural dog food brand for your dog involves evaluating ingredient quality, digestibility, and how well the formula matches your pet's individual needs. Best Online Pets Supply makes this process simpler by curating premium natural dog food brands and delivering them directly to your home with free shipping on qualifying orders. Shop Now to explore natural dog food alternatives that support your pet's long-term health and wellness.